top of page
Search

Streaming: On Swift Horses (2024) by Daniel Minahan: A sensual, melancholic odyssey through love, longing, and the illusions of the American dream

A gamble on love in a repressed America

On Swift Horses (2024) — directed by Daniel Minahan and based on Shannon Pufahl’s acclaimed novel — is a 1950s-set romantic drama that unfolds between the open roads of California, the neon lights of Las Vegas, and the dusty race tracks of the American West.

The film follows Muriel (Daisy Edgar-Jones) and Lee (Will Poulter), a young couple beginning their married life after the Korean War. Their new start is disrupted by the arrival of Julius (Jacob Elordi), Lee’s charming but restless brother. When Lee returns to military service, Muriel begins a secret life — gambling on horses, exploring her independence, and discovering a passion she never expected. Meanwhile, Julius embarks on a separate journey that intertwines with Henry (Diego Calva), a mysterious casino worker whose presence ignites both freedom and danger.

Through intersecting desires and betrayals, On Swift Horses becomes an erotic meditation on repression and risk, where love, like gambling, means surrendering control to fate.

Why to Recommend: A slow-burning tale of passion, repression, and identity

  • A visually rich period piece: Recreates 1950s California and Nevada with lush, cinematic detail.

  • Emotional subtlety: Captures the quiet, suffocating desires beneath the polished surface of postwar America.

  • Star power: Features Daisy Edgar-Jones, Jacob Elordi, and Will Poulter at their most vulnerable and magnetic.

  • Intersectional love stories: Queer and heteronormative relationships unfold with equal complexity and empathy.

  • Melancholic tone: Balances eroticism with emotional restraint — a story of longing rather than fulfillment.

Summary: On Swift Horses is a slow, elegiac love story where every stolen glance feels dangerous — and every touch feels like defiance.

What is the Trend Followed: Queer revisionism and neo-romantic Americana

Minahan’s film belongs to the new wave of revisionist American period dramas — reimagining mid-century life through marginalized perspectives.

  • Queer American reexamination: Joins films like Carol and Call Me by Your Name in rewriting hidden queer histories.

  • Female subjectivity: Muriel’s storyline reclaims the traditional “housewife” narrative as one of rebellion and awakening.

  • Cinematic nostalgia: Uses classic Hollywood aesthetics to critique the very myths they once upheld.

  • Psychological realism: Focuses on longing and alienation rather than melodrama.

  • Cultural duality: Contrasts the postwar ideal of conformity with the dangerous allure of autonomy and desire.

Summary: The film transforms the 1950s — often remembered for perfection — into a landscape of yearning, repression, and escape.

Director’s Vision: The American dream as a mirage

Daniel Minahan, known for Deadwood: The Movie and Halston, directs On Swift Horses with painterly patience and quiet sensuality.

  • Vision: To explore how love and identity can suffocate under societal pressure — and how freedom demands risk.

  • Aesthetic: Languid pacing, neon-drenched lighting, and analog textures evoke both nostalgia and claustrophobia.

  • Perspective: Dual narratives — Muriel’s domestic rebellion and Julius’s queer awakening — mirror each other’s search for belonging.

  • Tone: Intimate, erotic, yet mournful — a story told in whispers and silences rather than declarations.

  • Symbolism: Horses become metaphors for both speed and escape — beauty in motion, impossible to contain.

Summary: Minahan turns the American West into a psychological frontier — a place where freedom costs more than anyone can afford.

Themes: Desire, repression, and the illusion of freedom

  • Love vs. constraint: Passion collides with duty in a world obsessed with appearances.

  • Queer awakening: Portrays hidden lives lived in plain sight — coded glances and unspoken truths.

  • Chance and destiny: Gambling becomes a mirror for emotional risk and moral uncertainty.

  • Gender and power: Muriel’s rebellion challenges the gendered silence of mid-century womanhood.

  • The American façade: Beneath optimism lies emptiness — a nation built on dreams that exclude.

Summary: At its heart, On Swift Horses is about the price of authenticity — and the loneliness of freedom.

Key Success Factors: Mood, performances, and intimacy

  • Daisy Edgar-Jones: Anchors the film with quiet strength, capturing the restlessness of a woman on the edge.

  • Jacob Elordi: Balances charisma and melancholy as a man both predator and prey to his desires.

  • Diego Calva: Infuses tenderness and danger into his role, grounding the film’s queer dimension.

  • Cinematography: Golden-hour compositions and noir shadows create a sensual, almost dreamlike visual palette.

  • Soundtrack: Period music blends with original compositions to evoke nostalgia and longing.

Summary: The film’s beauty lies not in its action but in its restraint — in the way silence becomes more revealing than dialogue.

Critical Reception: Lush, ambitious, and emotionally fractured

  • The Guardian: “A visually intoxicating study of desire and deceit, if sometimes too languid for its own good.”

  • Variety: “Minahan directs with elegance and empathy, finding tenderness amid the moral dust of the 1950s.”

  • The Hollywood Reporter: “Jacob Elordi and Daisy Edgar-Jones deliver magnetic performances in a love story about impossible choices.”

  • IndieWire: “A film of yearning and distance — like watching love through glass.”

  • Audience consensus: Divisive but unforgettable; praised for its atmosphere and emotional subtlety.

Summary: Critics call it a “beautiful mess” — imperfect but haunting, a cinematic slow burn that lingers long after.

Audience Appeal: For lovers of slow, sensual, emotionally charged dramas

  • For fans of: Carol, Cold War, Call Me by Your Name, Far from Heaven.

  • Tone: Romantic, brooding, and reflective — where desire meets consequence.

  • Ideal audience: Viewers who appreciate emotional depth, period aesthetics, and slow storytelling.

  • Emotional takeaway: Teaches that love, like gambling, is an act of faith — and sometimes, self-destruction.

Summary: The film will resonate most with those drawn to quiet intensity and visual storytelling that trades action for atmosphere.

Industry Trend: The revival of queer period storytelling

On Swift Horses continues the renaissance of queer and female-led period dramas, where repressed eras become canvases for emotional liberation. Alongside films like My Policeman and Ammonite, it reconstructs mid-century America as both a site of beauty and quiet tragedy — a place where hidden lives shaped modern identity.

Cultural Trend: The slow cinema of emotion

This film participates in the postmodern romantic slow-burn — a movement toward introspection and stillness in contrast to digital overstimulation. It’s cinema for the patient viewer, where emotional payoff replaces spectacle.

Final Verdict: A beautifully restrained, emotionally turbulent portrait of love and risk

On Swift Horses (2024) is an ambitious exploration of how love and freedom collide in a world built on rules. Daniel Minahan’s direction and Daisy Edgar-Jones’ luminous performance turn this 1950s-set drama into a timeless reflection on longing, risk, and reinvention.Verdict: A slow, sensual, and deeply felt odyssey — love as chance, life as wager.


Comments

bottom of page