Beverages: Coca-Cola Considers Selling Costa Coffee: Market Realities and Strategic Shifts
- InsightTrendsWorld
- Aug 25
- 5 min read
Why It’s Trending: Global Brands Rethink Coffee Bets
Major Portfolio Move: Coca-Cola is exploring a sale of Costa Coffee, Britain’s largest high street coffee chain, just six years after acquiring it for £3.9 billion (over $5 billion USD) in 2019.
Financial Realities: Despite its size and brand power, Costa’s annual revenue in 2023 (£1.22 billion) remains below 2018 levels, with profitability impacted by rising costs and shifting consumer habits.
High Street Pressures: The UK retail landscape is incredibly challenging, with thousands of shop closures, changing work patterns, and competition from premium and convenience-focused coffee brands.
This development signals a broader rethink among global brands about how to achieve growth in a volatile, post-pandemic consumer and retail environment.
Overview: From Strategic Acquisition to Sale Consideration
Coca-Cola’s acquisition of Costa Coffee in 2019 was seen as a bold move to diversify beyond sugary drinks and compete with Starbucks and Nestlé in the high-growth global coffee market. However, Costa has faced a string of headwinds, including pandemic-related disruption, inflationary costs (coffee bean prices hit a 50-year high in 2024), evolving consumer tastes, and increased competition from both upmarket chains and DIY home coffee solutions. Now, Coca-Cola is working with investment bank Lazard, having held exploratory talks with potential buyers, including private equity firms. Indicative offers are expected in early autumn 2025, though the sale is not guaranteed.
Detailed Findings: Market Performance and Sale Dynamics
Costa trades from over 2,300 stores in the UK and Ireland, and 12,000 self-service Costa Express machines globally. Despite these numbers, recent years brought only modest revenue growth and persistent margin pressure.
In the last year, Costa’s high street locations have seen weaker demand, while its vending arm (Costa Express) continues to perform well.
The £3.9 billion paid by Coca-Cola is now contrasted with a reported potential sale price of around £2 billion—a £1.9 billion loss, reflecting the financial and market headwinds.
Coca-Cola CEO James Quincey has stated Costa is “not where we wanted it to be from an investment hypothesis point of view,” indicating internal frustration with the acquisition’s returns.
Costa’s challenges mirror broader issues on the UK high street: shop closures are at record highs (over 13,000 in 2024, with more predicted for 2025), footfall is down, and consumer spending is squeezed.
Rising premium competition (from brands like Gails) and remote working have also hurt Costa’s ability to maintain a clear advantage in both product and convenience.
Key Success Factors and Lessons: Why Costa Struggled
Market Timing: The acquisition was completed before COVID-19, which fundamentally reshaped how people shop, socialize, and consume coffee.
High Fixed Costs: A large physical footprint brings overhead challenges during downturns.
Consumer Shift: British consumers increasingly seek premium or homebrew coffee experiences, diminishing the “mass” model’s appeal.
Successful Segments: The Costa Express vending business stands out as resilient, offering speed and convenience to a changing consumer base.
Key Takeaway: Coffee Is A Tough Game—Even for Global Giants
The potential Costa sale underscores just how quickly retail and consumer preferences can shift—even for dominant brands. For large corporations, portfolio agility and a willingness to pivot are critical in a market landscape that rewards both innovation and operational discipline.
Main Trend: Strategic Retrenchment in Global Coffee
The global coffee industry is experiencing a period of correction, with international brands reassessing where growth can realistically be found. Physical stores face intensifying pressure, while vending and on-the-go solutions rise in importance.
Description of the Trend: “Retail Reset”—Coffee Chains Under Pressure
The “retail reset” in coffee highlights how changing consumer routines, rising costs, and competitive innovation are challenging once-dominant business models. Brands that fail to adapt quickly risk being left behind or forced into unplanned exits.
Key Characteristics of the Core Trend: Volatility and Value Reassessment
Aggressive Acquisition Reversal: Big-ticket deals questioned as market conditions change.
Rising Premiumization: Consumers willing to pay for better, less frequent experiences.
Convenience Reigns: Success in express, vending, and on-the-go segments.
Shop Closures: UK high street witness record numbers of permanent closures.
Innovation Requirement: Need for new formats, tech, and customer engagement.
Market and Cultural Signals Supporting the Trend
Cost Pressures: Coffee price spikes and inflation erode margins.
Consumer Fatigue: Mass-market appeal weakens as tastes become more sophisticated.
Changing Lifestyles: Remote and hybrid work reduce commuter foot traffic.
Private Equity Interest: Investors seek value in restructuring or repositioning struggling assets.
Competitive Heat: Both high-end and value coffee players squeeze the middle market.
What Is Consumer Motivation: Changing Coffee Habits
Seeking higher quality, premium experiences over quantity.
Embracing convenience and speed—favoring grab-and-go or vending over sit-down.
Discretionary spend is more cautious due to economic uncertainty.
Desire for novelty, personalization, and better digital integration.
What Is Motivation Beyond the Trend: Strategic Readjustment
Large brands need to adapt quickly to disruptive shifts in consumer behavior.
Emphasis is on core strengths (product excellence, tech, convenience) over scale alone.
Appetite for risk is recalibrated post-pandemic and following economic shocks.
Flexibility in format and distribution is prized by both brands and investors.
Descriptions of Consumers: The Evolving Coffee Shopper
Consumer Summary:Today’s coffee consumer is more selective and value-driven, seeking premium quality, convenience, and relevance to their individual routines. Mass loyalty is softening, replaced by polarization: frequent specialty shop visitors on one hand, and convenience-driven, cost-conscious consumers on the other.
Who are they? All adults, from office workers to students to home-based professionals.
What is their age? Broadly 18–60+, with younger consumers driving premiumization, and older consumers more convenience-focused.
What is their gender? All genders.
What is their income? All, but trends are stronger among those with moderate disposable income.
What is their lifestyle? Urban and suburban, digitally engaged, balancing time, quality, and affordability.
How the Trend is Changing Consumer Behavior
Coffee drinkers are migrating from “mass middle” chains to either premium/indie or ultra-convenient channels.
Frequency of in-store visits declines as home and express options rise.
Experimentation and loyalty are driven by value, quality, and experience—not just location.
Retailers and CPGs must innovate to earn repeat visits and anchor their relevance to daily life.
Implications Across the Ecosystem
For Consumers: More differentiated coffee experiences, but possible reduction in high street choice.For Brands: Focus on innovation, efficiency, and format agility is essential for survival.For Retailers: Pressure to optimize footprints, invest in vending/express, and partner for resilience.
Strategic Forecast
Costa’s outcome (sale or restructuring) will set a benchmark for retail coffee investment decisions.
Expect continued pressure on high street formats globally, with vending and convenience solutions gaining.
The premium/indie segment will keep widening its appeal to experience-driven consumers.
Large beverage brands will rebalance portfolios to focus on underexploited global opportunities and core competencies.
Areas of Innovation
Vending Tech & Express: Smart coffee stations and frictionless retail.
Premium Product Expansion: Single origin beans, advanced brewing, barista collaborations.
Experience Layering: Blending digital engagement with IRL coffee moments.
Flexible Store Formats: Smaller, multi-use, or pop-up locations.
Sustainability Focus: Ethical sourcing and waste reduction for value- and eco-conscious shoppers.
Summary of Trends:
Core Consumer Trend:Quality Over Quantity—Greater selectivity, with sharper focus on premium or convenient experiences.
Core Social Trend:The Decline of Mass Loyalty—Fragmented preferences and polarized coffee behaviors.
Core Strategy:Portfolio Agility—Big brands must reassess assets and double down on where growth remains viable.
Core Industry Trend:Retail Correction—Challenging headwinds for high street and mass-market chains.
Core Consumer Motivation:Informed Value-Seeking—Coffee drinkers weigh quality, relevance, and flexibility more than habit.
Final Thought: Agility Is Critical—Even for Global Leaders
Coca-Cola’s potential sale of Costa Coffee highlights how even the biggest players must remain nimble and open to recalibration. As coffee culture and retail undergo their own reset, only brands willing to shift with consumer behavior, innovate in experience, and invest in new models will capture the next wave of market growth.
Comments