top of page
Search

Coming Soon: After the Hunt (2025) by Luca Guadagnino: An elegant and unsettling moral thriller about guilt, truth, and the cost of intellect

A web of power, memory, and moral collapse

After the Hunt (2025) is a psychological drama-thriller directed by Luca Guadagnino (Call Me by Your Name, Bones and All) and written by Nora Garrett. The film follows Alma (Julia Roberts), a respected philosophy professor whose life begins to unravel when her star student Maggie (Ayo Edebiri) accuses a fellow professor of misconduct. As the academic scandal grows, Alma faces the resurfacing of a buried secret from her own past, forcing her to confront questions of ethics, complicity, and personal responsibility.

Co-starring Andrew Garfield, Michael Stuhlbarg, and Chloë Sevigny, the film is set within the cloistered world of an Ivy League university—where moral certainty and hypocrisy collide. With a script layered in ambiguity and emotional tension, Guadagnino crafts a sharp character study disguised as an intellectual mystery.

Premiering on October 17, 2025, After the Hunt has already sparked discussion for its fearless handling of sensitive themes and its powerful performances. The film earned a Metascore of 57, one win and one nomination, praised for its visual precision, haunting score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, and Roberts’s commanding return to serious drama.

Why to Recommend: A masterclass in tension, intellect, and emotional honesty

  • Julia Roberts in a career-defining transformation: As Alma, Roberts abandons her usual warmth for icy restraint. She plays a woman unraveling beneath intellect—a portrait of self-deception, denial, and guilt. Each gesture and glance carries the weight of secrets buried too long. This is Roberts at her most raw and cerebral.Her performance bridges the gap between authority and vulnerability, showing the cost of moral superiority when faced with personal failure. It’s a deeply human portrayal of control giving way to chaos.

  • Luca Guadagnino’s precision direction: Guadagnino turns academia into a psychological battlefield. His use of architectural framing, dim lighting, and long silences transforms lecture halls into interrogation chambers. Every scene hums with quiet menace, revealing more through pauses than words.He explores morality through mood and rhythm—allowing the audience to feel the intellectual and emotional dissonance Alma hides behind her eloquence.

  • Ayo Edebiri’s magnetic subtlety: As Maggie, she embodies the next generation questioning old power. Her quiet fury and calculated empathy make her both victim and challenger—a mirror to Alma’s past self. Their dynamic anchors the film’s philosophical weight.

Release date: October 17, 2025 (UK and US)

What is the Trend Followed: The rise of moral and intellectual thrillers

After the Hunt fits squarely within the modern resurgence of moral psychological dramas, films that dissect how ethics and emotion blur in the age of social awareness and academic politics.

  • The intellectual thriller revival: Following Tár, May December, and Anatomy of a Fall, Guadagnino’s film continues the trend of stories set in elite spaces where intellect becomes both shield and weapon. These films confront hypocrisy within “enlightened” institutions.

  • The fall of the authority figure: Alma’s unraveling echoes the broader cinematic movement of exposing moral fragility in figures of power—artists, teachers, and thinkers whose identities rest on control.

  • Ambiguous morality: Like recent A24 and Netflix dramas, it avoids moral binaries, forcing viewers to sit in discomfort rather than certainty.

  • Academic realism meets suspense: The film’s dense dialogue, campus debates, and quiet settings evoke real-world controversies while building thriller-like tension.

  • Feminine perspective on guilt: Guadagnino uses a female lead to explore gendered expectations of morality—how women in power carry both scrutiny and shame differently.

  • Aesthetic austerity: Muted palettes, slow pacing, and dissonant scoring define the “ethical thriller” style now dominating awards cinema.

Summary: After the Hunt exemplifies a new cinematic wave—films that challenge moral certainty, using intellect as both mirror and mask.

Director’s Vision: Beauty as tension, truth as discomfort

  • Human contradiction as art: Guadagnino paints Alma not as villain or victim, but as a mosaic of contradictions—a woman who intellectualized pain until it consumed her.

  • Cinematic philosophy: The film visualizes debate through space—hallways become moral corridors, classrooms become battlegrounds. Every shot invites the audience to judge and doubt simultaneously.

  • Sensual austerity: The director’s hallmark mix of elegance and unease turns academic life into something tactile, almost sensual, yet emotionally suffocating.

  • Emotional restraint: Guadagnino crafts tension through silence, allowing ethical questions to echo louder than confessions.

Themes: Guilt, power, and the illusion of virtue

  • Moral hypocrisy: The story dissects how those who teach ethics often fail to live them, exposing the frailty of intellectual morality.

  • Memory and denial: Alma’s buried past becomes the real antagonist—a meditation on how time reshapes guilt and truth.

  • Generational conflict: Maggie represents moral evolution, Alma embodies rationalization—their clash defines the film’s philosophical core.

  • Truth as performance: In academia, truth becomes currency; everyone edits their narrative to survive. The film questions whether honesty or reputation matters more.

  • The politics of perception: What we believe about others often reveals more about ourselves than about them.

Key Success Factors: Powerhouse performances and thematic depth

  • Complex screenplay: Nora Garrett’s writing balances ethical inquiry with emotional intimacy, offering dialogue that lingers long after it’s spoken.

  • Stellar ensemble: Garfield and Stuhlbarg provide quiet counterpoints—Garfield’s warmth contrasts Stuhlbarg’s unsettling intensity.

  • Visual and sonic immersion: The shadowed cinematography and Reznor & Ross’s discordant score pull viewers into Alma’s unraveling psyche.

  • Philosophical relevance: The film feels timely, mirroring current conversations about truth, academia, and moral accountability.

Awards & Nominations: Early prestige and critical discourse

After the Hunt premiered at the Venice Film Festival 2025, winning 1 award and earning 1 nomination for its screenplay and ensemble performance. Critics praised Julia Roberts for her reinvention and Guadagnino for crafting “an operatic chamber piece of ethics and decay.”While divisive, its ambition and artistry have made it one of the most discussed dramas of the year.

Critics Reception: A storm of intellect and unease

  • Variety: “A mesmerizing, uncomfortable study of guilt and perception—Roberts has never been this brittle or brilliant.”

  • The Hollywood Reporter: “Guadagnino builds tension like a mathematician. Every gesture counts, every silence condemns.”

  • IndieWire: “A modern Tár with softer light but sharper edges—a film that leaves you questioning where truth ends and defense begins.”

  • The Guardian: “Chilly, cerebral, and occasionally cruel—but impossible to look away from.”

Summary: Critics praise its intellectual rigor and emotional restraint, though some find its pacing glacial. It stands as one of Guadagnino’s most divisive yet artistically rich works.

Reviews: Audiences split but deeply engaged

  • IMDb Users: Rated 6.0/10, audiences praise the performances and dialogue but find the structure challenging and slow.

  • Festival attendees: Many describe it as “a film that doesn’t want to please—it wants to provoke,” highlighting Roberts and Stuhlbarg as unforgettable.

  • Letterboxd sentiment: Viewers call it “a masterclass in discomfort” and “Guadagnino’s most intellectually feral film.”

Summary: Viewers admire its ambition and artistry but warn it’s more a philosophical experience than a conventional drama.

Release Date on Streaming: Spring 2026

Following its theatrical release, After the Hunt will stream on Amazon Prime Video in March 2026, with a curated behind-the-scenes feature on its philosophical influences and performances.

Theatrical Release: Prestige fall debut

  • Release date: October 17, 2025 (UK and US)

  • Filming location: Cambridge, England

  • Production companies: Big Indie Pictures, Frenesy Film Company, Imagine Entertainment

  • Runtime: 2h 19m (139 min)Its fall premiere aligns with awards season positioning, reinforcing its place as one of 2025’s most anticipated prestige dramas.

Movie Trend: The moral reckoning narrative

Part of cinema’s ongoing turn toward ethically complex dramas, After the Hunt sits alongside The Zone of Interest and The Teacher’s Lounge in exploring how morality, guilt, and truth intertwine. The trend prioritizes reflection over resolution, letting ambiguity drive emotional impact rather than clarity.

Social Trend: The culture of accountability and its contradictions

The film mirrors real-world discourse on academic ethics, generational divides, and cancel culture. It examines how public morality often collides with private weakness, capturing the tension between justice and self-preservation. Guadagnino positions the story as a mirror to today’s fractured social conscience—where doing the right thing often comes too late.

Final Verdict: Intense, intelligent, and uncomfortably human

After the Hunt is a haunting moral labyrinth—a study of guilt, truth, and the fragility of ethical identity. With Luca Guadagnino’s elegant direction and Julia Roberts’s fearless performance, it delivers a slow-burning, cerebral experience that lingers long after the credits.Verdict: A darkly intellectual masterpiece—a film that dares to ask not who is guilty, but who dares to be honest.


Comments

bottom of page