top of page
Search

Streaming: Manodrome (2023) by John Trengove: The Dark Spiral of a Conflicted Man

The Incendiary Crisis of Masculinity

The film is a raw, psychological drama about a man's collapse into a misogynistic cult, nominated for the Golden Bear at the Berlin Film Festival.

Manodrome is a 2023 American-British drama and thriller film with a 15 certificate and a runtime of 1 hour and 35 minutes (95 minutes). It is written and directed by South African filmmaker John Trengove (in his U.S. debut). The plot centers on Ralphie (Jesse Eisenberg), a working-class man who is mentally and financially struggling with his pregnant girlfriend, Sal (Odessa Young). His life spirals out of control after he is seduced by a mysterious, celibate, and misogynistic "family of men" cult, the Manodrome, led by Dad Dan (Adrien Brody), which ignites Ralphie's repressed rage and latent violence.

  • The film premiered at the 73rd Berlin International Film Festival.

  • It was nominated for the prestigious Golden Bear and the Teddy Award for Queer Cinema.

Why to watch this movie. Unconventional Acting and Raw Punch

Watch for Jesse Eisenberg's transformative performance and the film's gritty, uncompromising look at male rage and cult radicalization.

  • The film features a "revelatory" and "best performance in over a decade" from Jesse Eisenberg.

  • He portrays a radically different role as a quiet, physically built, yet deeply disturbed protagonist, subverting his usual fast-talking persona.

  • His acting is praised for being "uncomfortable" and "explosive" as he embodies a character riddled with repressed rage.

  • Director John Trengove delivers a dark, dramatic thriller that is original, drawing inspiration from cinematic touchstones like "Taxi Driver" and "Fight Club."

  • The film offers a chilling allegory for the modern "incel-era" and online communities where alienated men find a distorted sense of belonging.

  • Oscar-winner Adrien Brody delivers a strong supporting performance as the cult leader Dad Dan.

  • Brody’s charming, nurturing manner acts as a disarming contrast to the explosive energy he fuels in Ralphie.

What Trend is followed? The New Toxic Masculinity Thriller

The film revitalizes the psychological thriller genre by using cult dynamics to dissect the modern male identity crisis and anti-feminist backlash.

The film follows the trend of the New Toxic Masculinity Thriller, a genre that uses psychological suspense and cult dynamics to dissect the modern male identity crisis, often focusing on men who feel powerless, lost, and rejected by mainstream society.

  • The central narrative trope is the radicalization of a troubled loner (Ralphie) by an organized group (Manodrome) that promises support.

  • The group instead weaponizes his inherent brokenness and victimhood complex.

  • The dynamic between the raw, repressed Ralphie and the suave, controlling Dad Dan explores different, yet equally dangerous, facets of fragile masculinity.

Director's Vision. The Pressurized Life of the Unexpressed Man

The director aimed to create a realistic "pressure cooker" situation, using emotional ambiguity and Ralphie's inability to express himself as the primary sources of tension.

  • John Trengove's vision is to put his protagonist in a "pressure cooker situation" where impending fatherhood, financial distress, and emotional isolation converge.

  • Ralphie's eventual violence is the chaotic result of emotions that "have boiled over" in a man who was never able to express himself.

  • The director deliberately leaves Ralphie's inner demons and the Manodrome's ultimate goal "in-conclusive" to avoid easy solutions.

  • This stylistic choice suggests that the complexity of real-life struggles rarely fits into a neat narrative box.

  • The story presents Ralphie’s quick descent into the cult's ideologies as a kind of addiction, a desperate, irrational craving for self-assurance.

Themes. Worthlessness, Repression, and Gendered Rage

The core of the film explores how a deep-seated fear of worthlessness, combined with repressed rage and sexuality, is exploited by misogynistic ideology.

  • The primary theme is Ralphie's fear of "worthlessness," exacerbated by job loss and the looming responsibility of fatherhood.

  • The cult preys on this feeling, offering him power and identity as a false antidote.

  • The film strongly hints that Ralphie is dealing with repressed sexuality and deep-seated childhood trauma (his father's abandonment).

  • The cult's hyper-masculine, celibate doctrine ironically serves to ignite the chaotic desires and rage he is trying to suppress.

  • The film explores the cult's misogynistic worldview, where society is disparaged as the "gynosphere."

  • This reflects a collective sense of victimhood and anger against women and shifting gender roles.

Key success factors. The Unforgettable Central Dual

The film's success is driven by the commitment of its two lead actors and the intense, believable tension their opposing personalities create.

  • Eisenberg's physical transformation and commitment to playing an unlikeable, unpredictable character drew immediate critical attention.

  • His acting defined the film's reputation as a serious psychological thriller.

  • Adrien Brody's subtly manipulative and "extremely perceptive" portrayal of the cult leader is key to the film's tension.

  • His charm is entirely believable as an influence on a man starved of self-assurance.

  • The film's "crude and sensationalizing" energy, featuring shocking twists and moments of intense psychological panic, ensures that despite its flaws, the film is a memorable and intense viewing experience.

Awards & Nominations. Golden Bear and Teddy Award Nominee

The film was recognized early on the festival circuit, earning two nominations at the Berlin International Film Festival.

The film was well-received on the festival circuit, earning 4 nominations total, including a nomination for the prestigious Golden Bear at the Berlin International Film Festival, and a nomination for the Teddy Award for queer cinema.

Critics Reception. Deeply Committed Performance, Flawed Execution

Critics are divided, praising the lead performance as career-best but finding the film's narrative too shallow to support its provocative political themes.

  • Rotten Tomatoes: Holds a 49% score based on critic reviews, with the consensus noting that Eisenberg's work is impressive, "even if the story isn't quite deep or nuanced enough to support his deeply committed performance."

  • Metacritic: Assigned a score of 48 out of 100, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.

  • The Playlist: Labeled the film the "Best Eisenberg offering in over a decade," but found the script to be a frustrating, "dreary mishmash" of classic tropes.

  • Collider: Praised the film for being a "gritty character study" that offered a "thoughtful exploration of toxic masculinity" and a strong warning about the dangers of enabling broken men.

  • Overall Summary: The consensus is that Eisenberg is phenomenal and the film is visually potent, but the narrative is often "muddled rather than provocative," failing to fully connect its themes of incel culture, misogyny, and repressed sexuality into a single, cohesive statement.

Reviews. A Wild, Uncomfortable Ride

Audience members are polarized, with many finding the film either intensely suspenseful or frustratingly bleak and inconclusive.

  • High Praise (7-8/10): Reviewers called the film a "wild ride" and an "Original, dark, dramatic thriller with a raw punch."

  • They appreciated the film's willingness to address the "pressure our young people are under."

  • Low Scores (3-4/10): A large number of users found the film "in-conclusive," "depressing," and a "waste of time."

  • These viewers claimed they could not relate to the unlikeable characters or the "nonsense script."

  • Overall Summary: The film is generally viewed as an intense, suspenseful, and unique experience by those who appreciated its experimental style, but deeply unsatisfying and often too bleak for a broader audience.

Movie Trend. The Cult of Despair

The film is a raw example of the Cult of Despair trend. This narrative uses a secretive, extreme, and insular group (like a masculinity cult) to dramatize the dangers of radicalization, offering an antidote to the protagonist's personal despair that leads to societal violence.

Social Trend. The Crisis of Male Fragility

The film taps into the major social trend surrounding the Crisis of Male Fragility and the rise of the "manosphere" and incel culture. It explores how emotionally unexpressed, financially insecure men turn to extreme ideologies when they feel emasculated or "trampled" by shifting societal expectations, resulting in a dangerous, misogynistic backlash.

Final Verdict. Jesse Eisenberg's Unforgettable Descent

Manodrome is a brave, demanding, and ultimately frustrating piece of psychological cinema. Director John Trengove succeeds in creating a visceral, intense atmosphere powered by a truly unforgettable performance from Jesse Eisenberg. While the film struggles with its ambitious goal to define the modern crisis of masculinity, it functions as a potent warning about the emotional time bomb created by repression and isolation. It is recommended for film students and audiences who appreciate uncomfortable, character-driven arthouse thrillers that prioritize mood and a raw central performance over neat plot resolution.

Similar movie. Sons of Anarchy: Psychological Thrillers of Male Fragility

  • Fight Club (1999): Classic film about a disillusioned man forming an underground club that escalates into an anti-consumerist, violent movement.

  • Taxi Driver (1976): A portrait of a psychologically isolated and emotionally unexpressed man whose loneliness and rage slowly drive him toward a violent outburst.

  • The Master (2012): Explores the intense, often destructive, psychological relationship between a charismatic cult leader and a troubled, emotionally damaged former sailor.

  • The Mastermind (2025): Explores the power struggle and mental chess game between two complex, troubled men.

  • Blue Ruin (2013): A raw, low-budget thriller about a homeless man seeking brutal, emotionally driven revenge for his parents' murder, showcasing the grim reality of a life spiraling out of control.



Comments

bottom of page