top of page
Search

Streaming: The Wailing (2024) by Pedro Martín-Calero: The Haunting Symphony of Untraceable Trauma

Summary: The Eerie Echoes of Intergenerational Grief

The Wailing is positioned as a modern, psychological horror film that sacrifices narrative clarity for overwhelming atmosphere, leveraging non-linear storytelling to explore the persistence of trauma across time and generations.

  • Catchy Title: The Haunting Symphony of Untraceable Trauma

  • Summary of Content: A non-linear psychological horror film that follows three young women—Andrea (2022/2023), Camila, and Marie (1998/1999)—across different eras and locations (Madrid, La Plata) whose lives become linked by an invisible, terrifying presence manifested by a "waning cry" of despair. The film blends supernatural dread with an investigation into family history and inherited pain.

  • Movie Trend: It belongs to the "elevated horror" subgenre, prioritizing sound design, sophisticated cinematography, and psychological discomfort over traditional jump scares and gore. It also follows the trend of global cinema (specifically Spanish-language) gaining international acclaim in the horror sphere.

  • Social Trend: The film taps into the modern cultural fascination with intergenerational trauma and the idea that pain and violence can be inherited or follow family lines, even if invisible or unexplained.

  • Director Info: Pedro Martín-Calero is a debut feature director who won a Best Director Award for this film, suggesting a strong visual and atmospheric command.

  • Major Awards and Nominations: 1 win (Best Director), and 4 total nominations, confirming its critical reception, especially regarding the direction.

Insights: Elevated horror is increasingly defined by its focus on psychological resonance and thematic complexity rather than narrative clarity or formulaic structure.

Insights for Consumers: This film is a strong choice for viewers seeking horror that uses genre elements to explore complex, human themes like inherited trauma and persistent grief.

Insights for Filmmakers: Non-linear structure is a viable tool for conveying generational trauma, effectively keeping a dark, persistent atmosphere without needing explicit exposition.

Why it is Trending: Aesthetic Horror and the Appeal of Ambiguity

The film's trendiness stems from its director's debut success, its blend of chilling atmosphere and complex character vulnerability, and the critical recognition it received, particularly for its innovative directional style.

The film is gaining attention because:

  • It successfully uses a familiar horror plot device—the invisible entity captured only on film—but elevates it through an interlocking, non-linear narrative that feels ambitious and intellectually engaging.

  • The reviews consistently praise the dense, suffocating atmosphere and the masterful use of sound (the "wailing" cry), making it a sensory experience that resonates with fans tired of formulaic horror.

  • The director, Pedro Martín-Calero, secured a Best Director Award, instantly positioning the film as a must-see for those interested in directorial vision and emerging talent in the genre.

Insights: Critical acclaim for debut direction can drive immediate market interest, validating the director's unique vision and distinguishing the film from mainstream genre fare.

Insights for Consumers: The consumer trend is the willingness to accept an open ending or unresolved plot if the emotional and sensory experience (sound, atmosphere) is strong enough.

Insights for Filmmakers: A highly sophisticated, singular atmosphere (driven by sound and visuals) can compensate for, and even benefit from, narrative ambiguity, attracting a niche but dedicated audience.

Why to Watch This Movie: A Masterclass in Psychological Discomfort

Watch The Wailing for its high-tension, anxiety-inducing atmosphere, exceptional visual language, and powerful ensemble performances, which combine to create a deeply unsettling and memorable viewing experience.

  • For the Atmospheric Tension:

    • The film achieves a "permanently oppressive, suffocating and disturbing atmosphere" by relying on latent tension rather than conventional jump scares. The constant, distressing, and hypnotic wailing acts as a character itself, ensuring a continuous sense of unease.

  • For the Visual and Sound Design:

    • Director Martín-Calero uses sophisticated visual techniques, including dark scenes, intelligent use of reflections, and a sound design that is consistently highlighted as masterful. This aesthetic choice makes the horror feel intelligent and deliberate.

  • For the Non-Linear Storytelling:

    • It successfully interweaves three seemingly separate timelines (1998, 1999, 2022, 2023) across two countries (Spain and Argentina). This structure challenges the viewer to actively connect the threads of trauma and haunting, rewarding patience with an ambitious narrative scope.

  • For the Strong Performances:

    • The lead actresses, particularly Malena Villa (Camila), are praised for shining in their roles, displaying a vulnerability that makes the characters relatable and their terror palpable. The focus is on human reaction to the unseeable.

Insights: Sustained, latent tension achieved through sound and visuals is a powerful and memorable alternative to traditional shock tactics in horror.

Insights for Consumers: The implied consumer trend is the desire for "smart" horror that stimulates empathy and reflection over purely visceral thrills.

Insights for Filmmakers: Investing heavily in technical and artistic execution (sound design, cinematography) pays off, particularly in the horror genre, where quality visuals and unique soundscapes often stand out.

What Trend is followed?: The Rise of Atmospheric, 'Smart' Global Horror

The Wailing firmly follows the contemporary "Post-Horror" trend, utilizing cinematic sophistication and non-linear structure to explore human themes like grief and family trauma, setting itself apart from mainstream genre fare.

The film is following the trend of Atmospheric Psychological Horror, often referred to as "Elevated" or "Smart" horror. This subgenre rejects reliance on gore and sudden shocks, instead focusing on slow-burn tension, dense atmosphere, and high-quality filmmaking that often includes complex or ambiguous narratives. Furthermore, it contributes to the significant trend of Spanish-language horror cinema gaining massive international critical traction, following the success of other recent releases from Spain and Latin America that prioritize mood and theme.

Insights: The "Post-Horror" movement emphasizes cinematic quality and thematic depth over conventional genre demands, securing broader critical appeal.

Insights for Consumers: The consumer market confirms a growing appetite for globally produced, subtitled content that actively pushes genre boundaries and offers intellectual engagement.

Insights for Filmmakers: Embrace narrative ambiguity as an artistic statement; the market validates risk-taking approaches in elevated genre cinema, especially from non-traditional filmmaking centers.

Movie Plot: Three Women, One Wailing Curse

The plot uses a tri-part, non-linear structure to track a singular, invisible force—manifested as a wail—as it torments three young women across different decades, forcing them to investigate a terrifying, shared history.

  • The Shared Element: The entire plot revolves around a distant, waning cry that signals the presence of an invisible evil. This sound is the ultimate unifying element.

  • Andrea's Timeline (2022/2023 - Madrid): Andrea is the primary protagonist who first hears the cry and feels the terrifying, unseeable presence chasing her, provoking violent acts. Her storyline acts as a modern investigation into the curse.

  • Marie's Timeline (1998/1999): Marie is haunted by the same harrowing force twenty years prior, connecting the present-day events to the past. The film centers on Marie and her immediate family's history, intertwining with the larger haunting.

  • Camila's Timeline (1998/1999 - La Plata, Argentina): Camila, a film studies student, is tormented by the wailing. She desperately tries to find an explanation, capturing the invisible force on film (video) and later live-stream (2022/2023), turning her experience into a quasi-documentary investigation.

  • Interlocking Narratives: The stories interlock through the "wailing" and a horrible presence tied to an eerie building, suggesting a cycle of familial depression, suicide, or trauma that follows the immediate family members and those affected by them.

  • Implied Movie Trend: The use of technology to capture the invisible (video, live-stream) reflects a modern horror trope, but the non-committal stance on whether the presence is "real" or a manifestation of familial depression elevates it into the psychological thriller realm.

Insights: A single, persistent sensory element (the wail) is highly effective as a unifying narrative device across fragmented timelines and settings.

Insights for Consumers: Fragmentation and complex timelines appeal to viewers who enjoy actively piecing together a puzzle while watching.

Insights for Filmmakers: Ambitious, multi-perspective narrative structures can maximize exposition and engagement in horror, successfully handling complex thematic elements like generational curses.

Director's Vision: The Aesthetics of Anguish

Director Pedro Martín-Calero's vision centers on crafting a sensory experience, utilizing meticulous sound design and high-end cinematography to create a palpable sense of anxiety and distress that serves as the foundation for the horror.

  • Focus on Sensory Experience:

    • Martín-Calero's direction is primarily concerned with creating discomfort and tension through meticulous attention to detail, especially light, sound, and silences. The sound design is paramount, turning the "wailing" cry into a central, hypnotic character.

  • Sophisticated Visual Language:

    • The director favors an aesthetic and cinematic visual approach. Scenes, particularly in Camila's timeline, are noted for being "maximally cinematic and, in a way, even aesthetic," prioritizing beauty and imagery over typical genre roughness.

  • Blending Horror with Human Vulnerability:

    • The film manages to be disturbing and unsettling while maintaining a deeply human story. Martín-Calero directs his lead actresses to display raw vulnerability, ensuring the audience empathizes with the victims' pain and trauma beyond the supernatural threat.

  • Ambiguity as a Tool:

    • The directorial choice to leave the main antagonist's past and intents without "clear exposition" is intentional. The horror lies in the untraceable nature of the presence and the lack of answers, leaving the audience in the dark and inviting reflection.

Insights: The director uses highly sophisticated visual language and sound design as primary tools to communicate emotional distress and theme, often superseding traditional dialogue or plot exposition.

Insights for Consumers: Audiences appreciate auteur-driven horror where the director's unique stylistic choices and technical polish are celebrated, even when the narrative is challenging.

Insights for Filmmakers: Prioritize emotional resonance and technical polish; exposition and clear antagonist motives can be sacrificed if the resulting mood and atmosphere are powerful enough.

Themes: The Inheritance of Suffering

The core thematic focus of The Wailing is the persistent, haunting nature of trauma and grief across generations, exploring how unseen violence can manifest both psychologically and supernaturally.

  • Trauma and Grief (The Wailing):

    • The central, eponymous sound embodies pure despair and suffering. The film explores how this profound, fundamental pain can become externalized as a haunting presence, suggesting trauma is something that literally 'stalks' its victims.

  • Invisible Presence and Paranoia:

    • The entity is invisible to the eye but detectable through technology, sound, and feeling. This dynamic explores themes of paranoia, mental instability, and the struggle to convince others of one's own harrowing reality.

  • Non-Linear Time and Intergenerational Horror:

    • By linking women in 1998 and 2022, the film explicitly addresses the concept of intergenerational trauma. The horror is not just a monster, but a cyclical family curse tied to history and a place (the eerie building).

  • Aesthetic Horror vs. Narrative Cohesion:

    • A meta-theme in the film is the presentation of frightening events. As noted in reviews, the film is "anxiously beautiful," suggesting the horror is intentionally aestheticized, mirroring the modern consumer's distance from and absorption with pain via screens.

Insights: Reframing supernatural elements as allegories for psychological or social issues (trauma, grief) adds significant thematic weight and critical relevance to a genre film.

Insights for Consumers: Consumers are increasingly drawn to films that use genre elements to facilitate deeper philosophical or emotional exploration.

Insights for Filmmakers: Successfully anchoring supernatural horror in a highly relatable social theme (like inherited trauma) gives the genre depth and allows it to transcend typical genre limitations.

Key Success Factors: Execution Over Explanation

The film's critical success rests on its stunning technical execution, including directional brilliance and sound design, coupled with an ability to sustain high-level psychological tension using strong female performances.

  • Direction and Cinematography:

    • Pedro Martín-Calero's debut direction, which earned him an award, is consistently praised for creating an immersive, disturbing, and visually sophisticated environment. The film is described as "impeccable" in its construction of setting.

  • Masterful Sound Design:

    • The specific, central element of the "wailing cry" is not just background noise but a key narrative and emotional device. The sound design is credited with creating constant unease and becoming the film's most striking feature.

  • Sustained Psychological Tension:

    • The film avoids the common pitfall of cheap jump scares, relying instead on a slow-burn, suffocating tension that keeps the audience alert and uncomfortable from start to finish.

  • Competent Lead Performances:

    • The ensemble cast, featuring Ester Expósito and Malena Villa, delivers convincing portrayals of vulnerability and distress, grounding the supernatural elements in realistic human emotion.

Insights: Technical brilliance, particularly in sound, can function as the film's most distinctive and successful narrative element, overshadowing reliance on plot.

Insights for Consumers: High-quality technical execution makes audiences more forgiving of narrative shortcomings and willing to engage with ambiguous endings.

Insights for Filmmakers: A distinctive, high-quality gimmick (the wail, the invisible presence) is often a stronger foundation for marketing and critical attention than a perfectly coherent plot.

Awards and Nominations: Recognition for Visionary Direction

The Wailing has received early critical recognition for its direction and overall quality, notably securing a win for its debut director.

The film has 1 win and 4 nominations total. The most significant win is a Best Director Award for Pedro Martín-Calero, signaling strong recognition for his visual execution and command of atmosphere in his feature film debut.

Insights: Best Director wins for debut features signal high-risk, high-reward visionary talent that the industry is keen to support.

Insights for Consumers: Award recognition serves as a strong signal for consumers seeking high-art or "elevated" genre cinema that excels technically.

Insights for Filmmakers: A focus on a unique vision and aesthetic command (direction) is often more likely to yield critical awards and industry attention than traditional, safer screenwriting.

Critics Reception: Atmospheric Triumph, Narrative Conundrum

Professional and user critics agree on the film's success in building tension and atmosphere, but are sharply divided on its narrative structure, with many finding the lack of closure and plot holes frustrating.

  • MLVC4E (User Review): Praises the dense atmosphere and the blend of supernatural horror with a deeply human story, noting the director's success in creating discomfort and tension without grand theatrics. Critiques the narrative for trying to tackle too much, leaving some aspects underdeveloped.

  • jabandrade (User Review): Lauds the oppressive atmosphere and impeccable setting construction, especially the sound design. However, finds the script severely lacking, stating the story "simply does not explain itself" and fails to provide a satisfactory conclusion despite the huge build-up.

  • gabriel_sanchez (User Review): Describes the film as "solid but lacks clear closure." Confirms it's strong on the horror aspect, cinematography, and depiction of timelines, but finds the storyline convoluted, with "holes seeming to creep into the plot points."

Insights: Polarized reception (high praise for aesthetics vs. plot criticism) is common and expected for highly ambitious, auteur-driven genre films.

Insights for Consumers: Viewers should go into the film knowing they will likely experience a trade-off: stunning atmosphere at the expense of clear narrative resolution.

Insights for Filmmakers: Be prepared for the trade-off: prioritizing atmosphere and visual poetry over traditional story resolution will likely result in a divided critical response but can generate strong word-of-mouth among cinephiles.

Reviews: A Collective Feeling of Captivating Unease

The overall sentiment across reviews is that the film is highly effective at creating captivating and prolonged anxiety, leading to a memorable experience despite widespread acknowledgement that the plot is frustratingly vague and leaves too many questions unanswered.

  • D0SKA (User Review): Calls the film "Anxiously Beautiful," highlighting the modern and genuinely frightening approach that avoids jump scares. Praises the non-linear structure for preventing boredom and notes that while the lack of answers is disappointing, the captivating tension makes up for it. Specifically praises Malena Villa's performance.

  • captainpass (User Review): Recommends the film as an "Excellent Horror-Thriller," appreciating the familiar plot device of the invisible presence elevated by the interlocking narratives that turn the film into a "Hitchcockian thriller-investigation." Enjoys the ambiguity of whether the presence is real or a manifestation of familial depression.

Insights: The ability to provoke a lasting, "unsettling feeling afterwards" is a key metric of success in the psychological horror niche.

Insights for Consumers: When sensory and emotional impact is high, the audience is more forgiving of narrative flaws.

Insights for Filmmakers: Focus on the initial emotional hook and sustained tension; if the feeling is strong and unique, the audience will tolerate narrative omission.

What Movie Trend film is following: Elevating Spanish-Language Genre Cinema

The film is a strong example of the international trend toward elevated and sophisticated genre filmmaking coming from non-English speaking markets. Specifically, it contributes to the rising reputation of Spanish and Argentine cinema in producing high-quality psychological thrillers and horror films that prioritize atmosphere, social commentary, and visual excellence over the mainstream Hollywood formula. It validates the ambition of directors to use genre to explore complex human conditions.

Insights: The global market is expanding its appreciation for visually sophisticated genre work from diverse linguistic origins, not just Hollywood fare.

Insights for Consumers: Consumers are driving the demand for non-English language cinema that pushes genre boundaries and offers a distinct cultural perspective.

Insights for Filmmakers: There is a major opportunity for international filmmakers to use genre vehicles (horror, thriller) to gain significant global critical and commercial traction.

What Big Social Trend is following: The Modernization of Ghost Stories as Trauma Narratives

The film directly engages with the contemporary social conversation surrounding intergenerational trauma (or inherited pain). By externalizing the "wailing cry" as a terrifying, physical presence that jumps across decades and family lines, it reframes the traditional "ghost story" or "curse" narrative as an allegory for persistent psychological and familial suffering that victims struggle to identify, name, or fight.

Insights: Successful genre films ground supernatural elements in relevant, contemporary social or psychological issues for thematic depth.

Insights for Consumers: Audiences are actively seeking emotional depth in their horror, where the monster is a metaphor for real-world pain and societal issues.

Insights for Filmmakers: Reframing traditional supernatural tropes (curses, ghosts) as allegories for societal issues (trauma, grief) provides critical relevance and emotional weight, elevating the material.

What Consumer Trend is following: The Demand for Intellectual Discomfort

Consumers in the horror market are increasingly seeking out films that offer intellectual and emotional challenge rather than purely visceral thrills. This film caters to the sophisticated horror consumer who prefers a slow-burn, atmospheric experience ("anxious beauty") that provides reflective staying power long after the credits roll, aligning with the success models of companies known for art-house horror.

Insights: The horror genre segment is increasingly catering to highbrow or "intellectual" tastes, moving away from purely commercial shock tactics.

Insights for Consumers: This film appeals directly to consumers who prefer a challenge and lasting reflection over easy consumption, valuing "anxious beauty" over immediate satisfaction.

Insights for Filmmakers: To cater to this audience, filmmakers should focus on visual and atmospheric polish ("anxious beauty") and ensure the film has reflective staying power.

Final Verdict: An Aesthetic Triumph, Narratively Unbound

Final Verdict: The Art of the Con, Perfectly Executed

The Wailing is a visceral and highly aesthetic psychological horror film that successfully uses masterful direction and haunting sound design to create an intensely sustained atmosphere of dread. While its ambitious non-linear plot struggles under the weight of its own ambiguity, failing to deliver the clear closure some viewers desire, its success in crafting pure, captivating discomfort makes it a significant debut for Pedro Martín-Calero and a powerful addition to the global landscape of "smart" horror.

Key Trend highlighted: The rise of atmosphere-driven, trauma-focused supernatural thrillers in global cinema. Key Insight: Narrative closure is secondary to atmospheric impact for a niche audience of intellectual horror fans.

Similar Movies: Echoes of Deep-Seated Dread

Films similar to The Wailing share a focus on psychological dread, non-linear narratives, and the use of the supernatural as a metaphor for deep-seated human trauma or anxiety.

  • The Babadook (2014) directed by Jennifer Kent: A horror film where the supernatural entity is a direct externalization of grief and depression, prioritizing psychological terror over jump scares.

  • Hereditary (2018) directed by Ari Aster: Known for its intense focus on intergenerational trauma and a slow, suffocating build of dread, showcasing high-art cinematography in the horror genre.

  • The Entity (1982) directed by Sidney J. Furie: Cited by one reviewer, this film shares the concept of an invisible, unseeable, yet physically terrifying presence that torments a female protagonist.

Final Insight on Market Positioning

For Filmmakers

The success of The Wailing demonstrates that genre films can command critical attention and win awards by investing heavily in technical and aesthetic excellence (sound, visual design) even if it means delivering an intentionally ambiguous or frustrating narrative resolution. For international filmmakers, this validates using non-linear, multi-perspective storytelling as a sophisticated tool to explore complex social themes (like inherited trauma) under the guise of horror.

For Consumers

This film is positioned for the modern horror audience seeking a viewing experience that prioritizes feeling over explanation. It markets itself as a contemplative, visually stunning piece of cinema that offers discomfort and reflection, appealing to those who enjoy global, art-house, or "elevated" horror rather than mainstream, plot-driven fare.

bottom of page