Restaurants: The Great Biscuit Debate: How a Viral Post is Redefining "Authentic" Food
- InsightTrendsWorld
- Sep 1
- 8 min read
What is the "Culinary Clash" Trend?
The "Culinary Clash" trend is a phenomenon where non-native food concepts, traditions, or ingredients are introduced to a new market, leading to a public debate. This is not just about a new product; it's about the emotional and cultural response that arises when familiar terms or ideas are used in an unfamiliar context. The trend is fueled by social media, where a simple question can quickly become a large-scale conversation about what is "correct" or "authentic."
Challenging Assumptions: The trend directly challenges a market's existing assumptions about a product. In this case, Mancunians' understanding of a "biscuit" as a sweet, dunkable item clashes with the American version, which is a savory, fluffy bread for sandwiches.
The Power of Digital Amplification: Social media platforms, particularly TikTok, act as a catalyst, turning a local debate into a viral sensation. This provides a massive, cost-free marketing opportunity for the brand at the center of the controversy.
A Focus on Authenticity: The trend is driven by a consumer desire for authenticity, but this term is often interpreted differently by various cultures. The debate highlights the tension between the owners' "authentic" American product and the locals' "authentic" British understanding of the same word.
Why It's Trending: Culture as a Marketing Engine
This story isn't just about a menu item; it's a perfect case study in how cultural differences can become a powerful marketing tool. The confusion and debate it generated are what made it go viral.
Free, Earned Media: The controversy creates organic buzz and media attention that money can't buy. By simply showing their product, Cardinal Rule received close to 2 million views in two days, turning a local business into a national talking point.
The Psychology of "The Insider": The debate created a sense of "insider" knowledge for those who already understood the difference between an American biscuit and an English scone. These individuals were motivated to "educate" others in the comments section, acting as free brand advocates.
Creating a "Must-Try" Product: The viral post made the American biscuit a curiosity. Whether people agreed with the name or not, the post made them want to see and taste the product for themselves. It created a powerful sense of curiosity and a desire to participate in the conversation.
Overview: From Local Spot to Viral Sensation
An American fried chicken spot in Manchester, Cardinal Rule, went viral on TikTok after a post showcasing their "biscuits" confused UK viewers. The video sparked a debate over the term, with many locals comparing the savory, fluffy American biscuit to the sweet, dense English scone. The owners, who are "used to it by now," are leveraging the confusion to attract customers, turning every new patron into a "convert" as they introduce a staple of Southern American cuisine to a new market.
Detailed Findings from the Case Study
The Power of Terminology: The entire controversy hinges on the single word, "biscuit." This shows how important clear and culturally relevant terminology is in marketing. While it caused confusion, it was also the exact reason the post went viral, serving as an effective marketing hook.
The Role of Education: Cardinal Rule's owners, who are "used to it by now," are in a position to educate their customers. They are turning every new customer into a "convert" who is trying a biscuit for the first time. This creates a memorable, educational experience that fosters brand loyalty.
A New Market for a Niche Product: The success of this post proves that there is a market for niche, authentic foreign food concepts, even if they require some initial customer education. The focus is on finding a balance between the familiar (fried chicken) and the new (the biscuit).
Key Success Factors of the Trend: Authenticity and Engagement
Authenticity: The owners' dedication to serving a genuinely authentic product, despite its potential for confusion, is a key success factor. This builds trust with consumers who are increasingly seeking out legitimate, non-commercialized experiences.
Digital Engagement: The brand's use of a short, engaging video on TikTok shows a mastery of social media. They didn't just post a picture; they created a piece of content that was designed to be discussed and shared.
The "Hero" Product: The American biscuit, a unique selling point in the UK, serves as the hero product that drives conversation and curiosity. It gives consumers a clear reason to visit their spot over a traditional chippy or burger joint.
Key Takeaway: The Controversy is the Content
The main lesson here is that in today’s social media landscape, controversy, when managed effectively, can be a brand's greatest asset. Instead of avoiding cultural confusion, Cardinal Rule leaned into it, using it to generate an unprecedented level of buzz and attention. The debate over a simple scone vs. a biscuit became the brand's most effective marketing campaign.
Main Trend: The "Glocalization" of Food
The main trend is the "Glocalization" of food, which is the process of a global product or concept being adapted to a local market. However, in this case, it's the inverse: a local, niche product from one culture (Southern American biscuits) being introduced to a new global market (Manchester, UK) and creating a fascinating clash of expectations.
Description of the trend: Heritage on a New Plate
This trend is a growing movement where small businesses and chefs are bringing authentic, regional dishes from their home cultures to new countries. Unlike large chains that adapt their menus to local tastes, these small businesses often maintain the authenticity of their dishes, even if it means clashing with local norms. This strategy is driven by a desire for authenticity and is often seen as a form of cultural exchange.
Key Characteristics of the Core trend: Storytelling and Audience-Centricity
The Centrality of a "Hero" Product: The trend often revolves around one specific, culturally distinct product that acts as the brand's unique selling point. For Cardinal Rule, that's the American biscuit.
Audience as Co-Creators of the Narrative: The brand's story is not just told by the owners; it's co-created by the audience who engages with the content, provides commentary, and spreads the word.
A Focus on Storytelling: These brands are not just selling food; they're selling a story—the personal journey of the owners, the history of the dish, and the cultural context behind it. This narrative adds an emotional layer to the product.
Market and Cultural Signals Supporting the Trend
The "Experience Economy": Consumers are looking for unique, authentic experiences, and trying a new, culturally distinct food provides a memorable one.
The Global Village: Social media has made the world smaller, exposing people to new cultures and food from across the globe. This has created a new level of curiosity and openness to trying different cuisines.
A Push for Authenticity: Consumers are becoming more skeptical of mass-produced, "inauthentic" food. They are drawn to small, local businesses that are passionate about their products and share their story.
What is consumer motivation?
Curiosity: The primary motivation for many is simple curiosity. The debate over what the product is, combined with the visual appeal of the fried chicken sandwich, makes them want to try it for themselves.
Social Currency: The product becomes a form of social currency. By trying it and sharing a photo or video, a consumer can show that they are in on the trend and part of the conversation.
Supporting Small Business: Many consumers are motivated to support small, local businesses that are following a unique passion and sharing their culture.
What is motivation beyond the trend?
A Desire for a Memorable Experience: Consumers are seeking more than just a meal; they want a memorable experience that they can share and talk about. The uniqueness of the American biscuit provides that.
The Search for Authentic Connections: In a globalized world, consumers are increasingly seeking out a feeling of authentic connection to a culture or community, and food is one of the most powerful ways to do that.
Description of consumers: The Discerning Food Explorer
Consumer Summary: This consumer is a foodie at heart, but they are also a cultural explorer. They are likely Gen Z or Millennials who are active on social media and trust peer reviews. They are driven by an appetite for new experiences and are often the first to try a new food trend and share it with their friends. They are not afraid to be part of a debate and often see it as a form of entertainment.
-Detailed summary (based on experience and article):
Who are them? Primarily Gen Z and young Millennials, and a broader group of food enthusiasts on social media.
What is their age? Generally 18-35.
What is their gender? The trend is gender-neutral.
What is their income? The price point of a fast-casual spot makes this accessible to a wide range of incomes.
What is their lifestyle? They are urban dwellers, socially active, and highly connected. Their lifestyle is a blend of local exploration and global curiosity.
How the Trend Is Changing Consumer Behavior: From Passive to Participatory
From Passive Consumption to Active Engagement: The consumer is no longer just a passive recipient of advertising; they are now an active participant in the brand's narrative through comments, shares, and their own content creation.
Trusting the Crowd over the Brand: Consumers are more likely to trust the opinions and experiences of a viral post and its comments section than a traditional brand campaign.
The Rise of a "Challenge" Mentality: The consumer approaches new food concepts with a "challenge" mentality—the challenge of trying something new, of understanding a cultural difference, and of being part of the conversation.
Implications of trend Across the Ecosystem
For Consumers: Access to a wider variety of authentic, global cuisines in local markets, leading to richer cultural understanding through food.
For Brands and CPGs: This trend provides a blueprint for small businesses to leverage cultural differences as a powerful marketing tool. It also shows larger brands that authenticity and a unique story can generate immense buzz.
For Retailers: Retailers, like the Northern Monk Refectory, can become cultural hubs that host unique food concepts, attracting a new and diverse customer base.
Strategic Forecast: The Era of Cultural Curation
Hyper-Niche Glocalization: More businesses will focus on bringing hyper-niche, regional foods from specific cultures to new markets.
Culture as a Business Strategy: Brands will intentionally create content that sparks cultural debates as a low-cost, high-impact marketing strategy.
The "Authenticity First" Model: Authenticity will become the primary metric for consumer interest, with a brand's story and genuine cultural roots being more important than its marketing budget.
Areas of innovation (implied by trend)
Cultural Branding:
Detail: Brands are innovating by making cultural differences their core identity. Instead of adapting, they are teaching and celebrating their heritage, turning a potential point of confusion into a brand strength.
Digital Storytelling:
Detail: The use of short-form video on platforms like TikTok is a key innovation. It allows brands to tell a compelling story in seconds and use the algorithm to find a global audience.
Community Building:
Detail: This trend is creating new ways for brands to build communities. By sparking debate, brands are creating a space for consumers to interact with each other and become part of a movement.
Menu and Concept Curation:
Detail: Retail spaces are innovating by acting as curators of unique food concepts. Rather than building their own restaurant, a space like Northern Monk is a platform for innovative food businesses.
Product-as-Experience:
Detail: The simple act of trying a biscuit for the first time becomes a memorable and shareable experience, transforming a simple food item into a cultural event.
Summary of Trends
Core Consumer Trend: The "Authenticity Seeker," a consumer who is driven by an appetite for new experiences and a desire for genuine, cultural connections through food.
Core Social Trend: The "Viral Culture Clash," where debates about food, terminology, and cultural norms become a powerful form of entertainment and social currency.
Core Strategy: The "Authentic Glocalization Model," a business strategy where small brands intentionally introduce a niche, culturally-specific product to a new market, using the resulting conversation as a marketing engine.
Core Industry Trend: The "Experience Economy" for Food, where food businesses are moving beyond just selling food and into creating unique, narrative-driven experiences that consumers are willing to pay for and share.
Core Consumer Motivation: A blend of curiosity and social validation, where consumers are motivated to try a new food to be part of a viral conversation and to feel like they are "in the know."
Final Thought: Authenticity Wins
The story of Cardinal Rule is a powerful example of how a simple food item can ignite a cultural conversation and change the way businesses market themselves. In a world of over-saturated trends, the real key to success might not be to fit in, but to be so uniquely authentic that you can't help but stand out. The debate over "scones" and "biscuits" proves that for today's consumer, a compelling story and a genuine product are worth far more than a costly marketing campaign.
Comments